ULA Launch Failure Tightens Space Force Capacity Bottleneck
Editorial responsibility
- No named human review is recorded for this page.
- Source reporting is collected, normalized, translated or condensed automatically when needed.
- Automatically published source-backed update
A United Launch Alliance (ULA) Vulcan Centaur rocket failed to reach orbit on November 15, destroying 40 Amazon LEO satellites and exacerbating existing launch capacity constraints for the U.S. Space Force. The failure, attributed to inadequate fuel supply to Blue Origin's BE-4 engines rather than engine performance itself, has intensified pressure on ULA as it relies solely on this vehicle for future missions. While SpaceX successfully tested its Starship, further cementing its dominance in heavy-lift capabilities, the incident highlights the fragility of a launch ecosystem dependent on shared components. Todd Harrison of the American Enterprise Institute described the situation as creating 'existential pressure' on ULA, noting that the Space Force is nearing the limit of its ability to swap missions to SpaceX's Falcon rockets. With SpaceX potentially phasing out Falcon 9 by 2028 and Starship certification pending, the Pentagon is exploring alternative vendors like Rocket Lab and Stoke Space, while considering the Defense Production Act to extend Falcon 9 operations.
Source report
By Air & Space Forces Association Audio of this article is brought to you by the Air & Space Forces Association, honoring and supporting our Airmen, Guardians, and their families. Find out more at afa.org.
The Vulcan Centaur Failure
On November 15, a United Launch Alliance (ULA) rocket failure resulted in an explosion that destroyed not only the vehicle but also the 40 Amazon Low Earth Orbit (LEO) satellites it was carrying. This incident has exacerbated the existing bottleneck constraining Space Force launch capacity and intensified pressure on ULA.
The Vulcan Centaur launch marked the first flight for the rocket in nine months, following a lengthy investigation into a February anomaly involving solid rocket boosters manufactured by Northrop Grumman. While the recent launch began successfully, it failed approximately 10 minutes into the flight. Investigators concluded that the rocket did not reach a high enough altitude or develop sufficient velocity to achieve orbit.
Root Cause: BE-4 Engine Fuel Supply
According to ULA statements, the failure was caused by an "inadequate fuel supply from the vehicle to the BE-4 engines," rather than a performance issue with the engines themselves. These engines are built by Blue Origin.
- Implications for Blue Origin: While this finding may be positive news for Blue Origin, it raises concerns because the same BE-4 engines power the New Glenn heavy-lift vehicle.
- New Glenn Status: The New Glenn rocket has been grounded since May, following an explosion on the pad at Cape Canaveral Space Force Station, Florida. Blue Origin currently plans to launch a New Glenn in January 2027, with no indication of schedule changes.
This incident highlights the fragility of a launch ecosystem where multiple vendors share key components. An issue with the BE-4 engines could threaten two of the Space Force's three launch options for its most critical National Security Space Launch (NSSL) missions.
"Existential Pressure" on ULA
Todd Harrison, a defense space and budget expert with the American Enterprise Institute, described the situation as creating "existential pressure" on ULA.
- Resolved Issues: There is some good news; ULA appears to have resolved issues with the Vulcan Centaur's solid rocket motors (built by Northrop Grumman), which were blamed for the February grounding. A Northrop Grumman spokesperson confirmed their boosters "performed as expected and successfully separated from the Vulcan launch vehicle before [the] anomaly."
- Fundamental Reliability: Harrison noted that the fact that the first stage has performed in the past suggests the issue is not fundamental. "It was a lower probability event, and it just happened to occur," he said.
- Strategic Risk: Despite this, ULA has bet its future entirely on the Vulcan Centaur. "Every day they're grounded, they are falling further and further behind on the orders they already have, which is preventing them from taking on any new orders," Harrison explained.
Space Force Response and Mission Swaps
The Space Force has voiced continued support for ULA. Brig. Gen. Eric Zarybnisky, the service's portfolio acquisition executive for space access, stated:
"Our office remains fully committed to our partnership with United Launch Alliance and the long-term success of the Vulcan Centaur program... While the outcome is not what the team worked toward, our focus remains on supporting ULA in a rigorous, data-driven analysis to identify the cause, implement corrective actions, and return to flight safely."
However, the Space Force faces immediate mission requirements. They have already swapped half a dozen missions from Vulcan to SpaceX's Falcon 9 or Falcon Heavy rockets, anticipating ULA would recover later. Harrison warns this strategy may be reaching a breaking point:
- Falcon 9 Capacity: The Falcon 9 is operating at almost its maximum flight rate.
- Limited Flexibility: There are fewer missions the Space Force wants to delay and little remaining capacity to swap.
- Future Outlook: This scarcity raises the specter that the Space Force and other customers must begin looking at alternative vendors.
Currently, only SpaceX has launch vehicles cleared for NSSL missions. Even if Blue Origin returns to flight with a commercial mission in January, it must still complete the Space Force's certification process for no-fail NSSL missions (though it can offer options for less critical missions).
Pentagon Support for New Vendors
To hedge against these risks, the Pentagon is offering $150 million in loans to support new rockets from smaller providers Rocket Lab and Stoke Space. Both companies are scheduled for their first flights in 2027.
SpaceX's Strategic Shift: Starship vs. Falcon 9
SpaceX's November 14 Starship launch was the 15th attempt in three years for the 400-foot-tall rocket, exemplifying the company's approach of frequent testing and rapid iteration.
- Mission Success: The rocket reached low-Earth orbit, deployed its payload of new Starlink satellites, and successfully returned its upper stage to the launch site in Texas to be caught by mechanical arms. Officials canceled an attempt to catch the lower booster stage, but the mission was otherwise hailed as a success.
- Resource Allocation: SpaceX is devoting increasing resources to Starship while simultaneously backing off work on the Falcon 9, which remains the workhorse for the Space Force and commercial industry.
- Commercial Orders: Media reports indicate SpaceX has stopped accepting commercial orders for Falcon 9 launches beyond 2028. The Space Force retains slightly more time, able to order launches through the current phase of the NSSL program until 2029, with launches extending several years beyond that.
The Certification Challenge
While the Falcon 9 will eventually retire, Starship is not a guaranteed replacement due to its unique design. When asked if SpaceX is seeking certification for national security launches, a Space Force spokesperson deferred to the provider, noting that "the certification process is initiated by the launch-service provider."
Harrison highlighted a specific design mismatch:
- PEZ Dispenser Design: SpaceX's Starship features a unique design developed to release small Starlink satellites in low-Earth orbit, not conventional large spacecraft typical of national security launches.
- Recommendation: Harrison suggested SpaceX could alleviate fears by providing a timeline for a different Starship version equipped with a payload bay or fairing capable of launching traditional satellites.
Potential Government Interventions
With limited options, the government may need to take drastic measures to ensure launch continuity. Harrison suggested the Defense Production Act (DPA) could be utilized to force SpaceX to keep the Falcon 9 flying longer.
- Defense Production Act: Under the DPA, the President can "require acceptance and performance of … contracts or orders" deemed necessary for national security. As noted by Alan Z. Rozenshtein for Lawfare, this could potentially force a company to accept new work, though the limits of this authority remain undefined and untested in this context.
- Alternative Solutions: Others have suggested licensing Falcon 9 technology to other companies like ULA or requiring SpaceX to spin off Falcon 9 operations into a separate business. However, Harrison cautioned that both options face significant hurdles, including the loss of institutional knowledge and lengthy bureaucratic processes that may lack political support.
Source
Air & Space Forces MagazineWestern
Part of this Story
ULA Vulcan Centaur Rocket Fails Mid-Flight, Destroying 40 Amazon Satellites