Analysis: Parties leaning on social media provocation defeated in Brazil, US and Israel elections
Editorial responsibility
- No named human review is recorded for this page.
- Source reporting is collected, normalized, translated or condensed automatically when needed.
- Automatically published source-backed update
An analysis by Le Monde journalist Damien Leloup observes that recent elections in Brazil (October 25 presidential), Israel (legislative, two days later), and the United States (midterms, November 3) resulted in defeats for hard-right parties that had heavily invested in online provocation, outrage, and symbolic violence—so-called trolling. In Brazil, supporters of Flavio Bolsonaro used personal attacks, AI-generated images, and disinformation against rival Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva on X, Facebook, and WhatsApp. In Israel, Likud and far-right minister Itamar Ben Gvir circulated AI-generated content, including a video of obese Palestinian prisoners undergoing forced weight loss, which garnered millions of views. The article argues that while social media algorithms reward radical and caricatured content, such clicks do not translate into votes and can repel undecided voters needed to win a majority.
Source report
Brazil's presidential election on October 25, Israel's legislative elections two days later, and the US midterms on November 3: in quick succession, in all three countries, hard-right parties lost their elections. Beyond the specific features of local political situations and the reasons for these electoral failures, these three votes saw the defeat of parties that had bet, on social media, on provocation, excess, and symbolic violence to attack their opponents—in a word, what is known in English as trolling.
Brazil: Personal Attacks, AI Images, and Disinformation
In Brazil, personal attacks, images generated by artificial intelligence (AI), and false information were used by Flavio Bolsonaro's supporters to attack his rival, Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva, on X, Facebook, and WhatsApp.
Israel: AI-Generated Content and Provocation
In Israel, the legislative campaign was also marked by the proliferation of AI-generated content, broadcast in particular by Likud, Benyamin Netanyahu's party. National Security Minister Itamar Ben Gvir (far right), accustomed to threats and provocations both online and offline, notably circulated an AI video, viewed several million times, showing obese Palestinian detainees undergoing a forced weight-loss cure in an Israeli prison. Exactly the type of images that garner enormous quantities of "likes" from the most extremist activists and voters, and provoke shocked comments from opponents—which propels the video through the algorithms and drives up view statistics.
Read also | Subscriber-only article Legislative elections in Israel: candidates flood the campaign with AI-generated deepfakes
Read later
Clicks Do Not Equal Votes
But here's the thing: these clicks do not mechanically translate into ballots. Worse, they give a distorted impression of the real support enjoyed by a candidate, a party, or an idea. The very mechanics of social media encourage the most radical and most caricatural personalities and proposals; but offline, this same radicality can act as a powerful deterrent, particularly among undecided voters, who are precisely the people one must convince to win a majority.
You have 65.42% of this article left to read. The rest is reserved for subscribers.
Source
Politique : Toute l’actualité sur Le Monde.fr.Western