Left-Wing Critics Challenge Anti-Semitism and Islamist Alliances

This analysis explores the internal divisions within the global left regarding anti-Semitism, Zionism, and political Islam. It highlights that some of the strongest critics of anti-Semitism and the 'red-green alliance' between leftists and Islamists are themselves rooted in left-wing traditions, particularly Marxist political economy and Frankfurt School critical theory. The article argues that post-structuralist and post-colonial trends in academia since the 1990s have led to a taboo against criticizing orthodox Islam and increased cooperation with Islamist movements. In contrast, parts of the Antifa movement and certain left-wing intellectuals actively oppose anti-Israel demonstrations and reject fraternization with jihadist groups. The piece cites specific examples, such as German politician Heidi Reichinnek's past advocacy for ties with the Muslim Brotherhood, versus former Berlin Culture Senator Klaus Lederer's distancing from his party following the October 7, 2023 Hamas attacks. The author contends that terms like 'Islamophobia' are often used to shield Islamic regimes from criticism, urging a return to classical critical theory to address these ideological conflicts.