ECFR: Europe must proactively propose security framework to avoid being set by Russian agenda
Editorial responsibility
- No named human review is recorded for this page.
- Source reporting is collected, normalized, translated or condensed automatically when needed.
- Automatically published source-backed update
Following the Trump administration's acceptance of Russia's demand to renegotiate European security architecture as part of Ukraine war negotiations, the European Council on Foreign Relations (ECFR) argues that Europeans must proactively formulate their own proposal. Moscow has long demanded a rollback of NATO's presence and a halt to enlargement, including regarding Ukraine. The ECFR warns that waiting for Moscow to set the agenda risks framing the debate around Russian terms rather than achieving a ceasefire. While acknowledging that Russia likely opposes core principles like territorial integrity, the article suggests Europeans should propose deconfliction measures and reaffirm Helsinki Final Act principles to shape the inevitable discussion. This approach aims to prevent a scenario where Europe is excluded from decisions defining its own security.
Source report
Problem: Accepting Russia's Agenda
The Trump administration has accepted Russia's long-standing demand to renegotiate the European security architecture as a condition for ending the war in Ukraine. Moscow has insisted on this for years, having previously submitted two draft agreements to NATO and the US in December 2021. These drafts included the following core demands:
- No further NATO enlargement, with explicit reference to excluding Ukraine.
- Rollback of NATO's military posture to 1997 levels, requiring the withdrawal of troops and weapons from frontline states.
- Prohibition of US military bases, NATO military activities, or bilateral military cooperation with non-NATO former Soviet states.
- Ban on intermediate- or short-range missiles capable of reaching each other's territory.
- Removal of American nuclear weapons from Europe.
Reluctance and Strategic Risks
European and Ukrainian leaders have been highly reluctant to initiate discussions regarding the European security architecture with Moscow prior to establishing peace in Ukraine. Their primary argument is that Russia must first cease violating the existing security order.
There is a prevailing concern that the United States has walked into a trap by agreeing to discuss these terms and inviting Moscow to formulate proposals. Since these proposals will almost certainly mirror the December 2021 demands, accepting them allows Russia to:
- Frame the debate.
- Set the negotiation agenda.
- Shift focus away from achieving a ceasefire in Ukraine.
Furthermore, Europeans have expressed dissatisfaction that their security is being discussed without their direct involvement. However, there is evidence that US negotiator Jared Kushner recognizes the logic of including European stakeholders; he has reportedly attempted to persuade Vladimir Putin to allow European participation in the talks.
Solution: A Proactive European Proposal
Rather than waiting for Moscow to define the parameters of the discussion, Europeans should rapidly develop their own proposal for revising the European security order. This proposal could encompass the following elements:
Principles
The goal should be to reaffirm the principles established in the Helsinki Final Act, specifically:
- Respect for territorial integrity.
- The right of states to choose their alliances.
- Refraining from the threat or use of force.
Deconfliction and Risk Reduction
Europeans should propose specific mechanisms to reduce tensions, including:
- Establishing a military-to-military hotline for deconfliction.
- Agreeing on maintaining safe distances between aircraft and warships.
- Committing to the use of GPS and AIS transponders while refraining from jamming signals.
- Pledging not to violate each other's airspace.
- Setting up a mechanism for observing military exercises and allowing inspections.
- Progressing disarmament and arms control talks.
Strategic Outlook
While it is unlikely that Moscow will agree to these proposals—given its opposition to the underlying principles (evidenced by the war in Ukraine) and its interest in unpredictability and escalation—the act of presenting a European proposal would fundamentally shape the inevitable discussion.
Context: Russia's Objectives vs. European Reality
Russia's desire to revise the European security order is driven by a wish to diminish American influence and security commitments in Europe, thereby gaining greater control over the continent. In Moscow, there are aspirations to create a new "Yalta Agreement" that divides Europe into spheres of influence, granting Russia veto power over European security.
However, following Russia's brutal invasion of Ukraine, no scenario exists where Europeans would accept less security than they currently possess. Today, European security is defined in opposition to Russia, rather than incorporating Russia as a partner.
Note: The European Council on Foreign Relations does not take collective positions. ECFR publications represent only the views of their individual authors.
Source
European Council on Foreign RelationsNeutral / independent