Wire flash
Volkswagen posts €5.82bn quarterly loss after €6.4bn Porsche writedown
Editorial responsibility
- No named human review is recorded for this page.
- Source reporting is collected, normalized, translated or condensed automatically when needed.
- Automatically published source-backed update
Volkswagen reported a 5.82 billion euro after-tax loss in the third quarter of 2026, driven not by operating shortfalls but by a 6.4 billion euro writedown on its Porsche stake. Guest commentator Stephan Kaufmann argues the loss is a pure book loss with no cash outflow, noting VW earned 8.8 billion euros operating profit in the first nine months and more than doubled its automotive cash flow to 4.4 billion euros. Left Party leader Luigi Pantisano called the loss 'above all an accounting trick.' Kaufmann explains that company value in capitalism depends on expected future profits, so a downgraded outlook for Porsche—due to weaker luxury demand, US tariffs, and Chinese competition—immediately reduces VW's book value. He argues this shows capitalist wealth is speculative and volatile, contingent on perpetual growth and returns rather than product quality or innovation, and that management uses such losses to justify plant closures and job cuts.
Source report
Guest commentary by Stephan Kaufmann | November 16, 2026, 7:12 AM
Porsche emblem for hoods: Prosperity in capitalism is speculative and therefore susceptible to fluctuations. Photo: Marijan Murat/dpa
"Germany must become the growth locomotive again," demands Chancellor Friedrich Merz. Without growth, he says, our prosperity is in danger. But why should this prosperity be threatened simply because it is not increasing? An answer to this question is currently being provided by the crisis of a cornerstone of the German economy: Volkswagen.
The Volkswagen Group suffered a severe loss in the third quarter of 2026: €5.82 billion after tax. The cause of the loss was not that Volkswagen spent a lot of money and took in much less. Rather, it was so-called special effects, above all a write-down on its stake in Porsche of €6.4 billion. In other words: In VW's corporate books, the Porsche stake was devalued by €6.4 billion, which represents an accounting loss of assets. The deeply negative balance sheet, in turn, serves as management's justification for the planned closure of plants and the elimination of tens of thousands of jobs.
Luigi Pantisano, party chairman of the Left Party, sees this loss as "above all an accounting trick." For while the Porsche devaluation means a loss of €6.4 billion, Pantisano argues, "not a single euro leaves the cash register here. Without special effects, VW earned €8.8 billion operationally in the first nine months. Cash flow in the automotive business more than doubled, to €4.4 billion. … That's not what a company on the brink looks like." Is there anything to this criticism?
Stephan Kaufmann works as a freelance author for the weekly edition of "nd," among other outlets. He has worked as a business journalist for 25 years, formerly for the Frankfurter Rundschau and the Berliner Zeitung. He studied business administration and economics in Berlin and Paris.
It is true that the Porsche write-down means no real outflow of money for Volkswagen; the group has not spent €6.4 billion that is now missing. Without the Porsche write-down, its net profit would have been significantly better—presumably even positive. The write-down is a pure book loss.
Prosperity in capitalism is not a question of quality and innovation
Nevertheless, it is real. It arises because Porsche's business prospects are being assessed less favorably. Declining demand for luxury cars, US tariffs, and competitive pressure in China are likely to mean that Porsche will deliver less profit to Volkswagen. And since Porsche's current value depends on this future profit, that value is being revised downward—costing Volkswagen €6.4 billion.
That a company's value is measured by whether and to what extent it generates a profit is not a peculiarity of Volkswagen but capitalist normality. From the perspective of investors, a company is all the more valuable the more return it generates or promises to generate. The higher the expected profit, the higher the price that justifies a purchase—and a company that foreseeably generates no profit or even losses is worth precisely nothing.
Thinking on a larger scale: In capitalism, the financial and productive wealth of society stands and falls with whether this wealth is a means to—in business-school German—the net asset increase of its owners. This is why the shareholders of real estate companies also complain of "expropriation" when rent price regulations endanger their freedom to raise rents and thus their returns, causing their investment to lose value.
Value and prosperity are therefore not questions of the quality of the goods produced, not a question of innovation, technological standing, or the "scarcity" of a thing. All of this counts only in one respect: insofar as it benefits the return. What does not serve this purpose is worthless from an investor's perspective.
taz debate
The taz is an independent, left-wing, opinionated daily newspaper. In our commentaries, essays, and debate texts, we have been arguing since the founding of the taz in 1979. Often we cannot and do not want to agree on a single opinion. That is why you will find sometimes completely opposing positions here—all part of the very broad left-wing spectrum of opinion.
Therefore, in capitalism, prosperity is threatened when it does not grow permanently. Or more precisely: It is threatened when its growth threatens to fall short of expectations. For here, only the future counts. Prosperity in capitalism is speculative and therefore susceptible to fluctuations, as the Volkswagen/Porsche example shows: Since a company's current value depends on future earnings, an expected decline in future earnings already leads to an accounting loss today—even though the company itself is intact.
The valued company is essentially dependent on its speculative valuation. For it is on the basis of this metric that its financiers—banks, funds, shareholders—decide whether to grant it loans or equity for its further growth, and at what price. This is why a company's share price is an important metric for investors, because it reflects, or is supposed to reflect, expected earning power.
Always keep working diligently
The wealth of the world—that is, global assets in the form of companies and financial investments—was estimated by the research division of the consulting firm McKinsey in 2025 at around $1,800 trillion—a record figure. But McKinsey has doubts about whether this valuation is also "healthy." It could "only be interpreted temporarily as a sign of confidence in future economic growth."
Whether this confidence, and thus the assets, are also justified depends on whether expected returns are actually delivered: "Only an acceleration of productivity," McKinsey explains, "creates real economic growth that justifies the valuations and thus protects the wealth."
The wealth of the world in the form of accumulated assets is therefore, on the one hand, the wealth that is available. But its magnitude stands and falls with its multiplication, which is measured by return. Ensuring this growth remains the task of governments, of societies, and of the population. "Our prosperity" (Merz)—that is, the speculatively projected stock, bond, corporate, and real estate values—is therefore above all one thing: a demand on the population to preserve and increase these values through permanent multiplication, that is, to always be diligently hardworking and cost-effective. Wealth in capitalism has a voracious nature.
Feedback: Comment | Report an error
Related articles:
- Threatened VW plant in Zwickau: And the AfD rubs its hands — Commentary by Gunnar Hinck
- VW plant Osnabrück: Arms deal to save Volkswagen — By Harff-Peter Schönherr
- Declaration of war on the workforce: Volkswagen seeks maximum confrontation — By Anja Krüger and Pascal Beucker
0 Comments
Most read:
- Wolf Biermann interview: "The East always drew the short straw"
- Authoritarianism study: Questioning neoliberal beliefs
- AfD candidate for federal presidential election: Football is also right-wing
- The Vanessa Emde case: The long run-up to exclusion
- Agreement on the 2027 federal budget: The real distribution struggles are yet to come
- For more societal modesty: Just be satisfied with a little less!
Source
taz.de - taz.deWestern