Review: A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms as a Critique of Occupational Licensing

This review from Reason.com analyzes the first season of HBO's Game of Thrones spinoff, A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms, interpreting its central narrative through the lens of occupational licensing. The article highlights the ambiguity surrounding the protagonist, Duncan the Tall, and whether he holds the official title of knight. Despite lacking formal credentials, Dunk demonstrates the virtues of knighthood through bravery, justice, and defense of the innocent. The reviewer draws a parallel between the fictional threat of execution for falsely claiming knighthood and modern regulatory burdens faced by professionals like hair braiders and cosmetologists. While acknowledging that modern penalties are less severe than capital punishment, the author argues that both systems impose silly and unnecessary restrictions on individuals who perform their duties competently without state-sanctioned permission. The piece uses the fantasy drama to critique the broader concept of occupational licensing, suggesting that competence and ethical conduct should matter more than bureaucratic certification. Ultimately, the review posits that the question of Dunk's official status is secondary to his actual actions and character, serving as a metaphor for the inefficiencies of modern regulatory frameworks.