ICE pays AT&T millions to access trillions of phone records
Editorial responsibility
- No named human review is recorded for this page.
- Source reporting is collected, normalized, translated or condensed automatically when needed.
- Automatically published source-backed update
Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) is paying AT&T millions of dollars to access raw data and analytical services, a program civil liberty experts describe as mass surveillance. According to documents obtained by 404 Media, the arrangement allows ICE analysts to sift through trillions of phone records and location data, potentially affecting non-AT&T customers via wholesale connections. Critics, including Senator Ron Wyden and surveillance expert Christopher Soghoian, argue this 'zombie version' of the former Hemisphere program bypasses judicial oversight by relying on administrative subpoenas rather than warrants. The contract, valued at over $2 million annually with potential growth to $10 million, enables ICE to link devices, track SIM changes, and monitor international targets. While AT&T claims the data is provided under valid legal orders, privacy advocates warn the lack of court approval and privacy impact assessments creates significant risks for abuse.
Source report
By 404 Media
Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) is paying telecommunications giant AT&T millions of dollars to have its analysts sift through vast amounts of raw data for a wide variety of investigations. According to an internal ICE document obtained by 404 Media, along with other procurement records and expert analysis, the program allows access to trillions of phone records and location data. Civil liberty experts have characterized this arrangement as a mass surveillance program.
The "Zombie" Hemisphere Program
The AT&T product, interchangeably referred to as Data Analytics and Support Services or Data Analytical Services, appears to be a continuation of the earlier Hemisphere surveillance program. Under Hemisphere, AT&T provided U.S. authorities at state, local, and federal levels with access to user data. Although that program was officially shut down, ICE continues to pay for access to raw data under this new arrangement.
"This requirement provides ICE access to AT&T's raw data and experienced analysts," reads the restricted ICE procurement document obtained by 404 Media.
Scope of Data Collection
The program likely affects more than just AT&T customers. Because AT&T connects calls for other phone companies, non-customers are also swept up in the data collection.
- Wholesale Access: Christopher Soghoian, a surveillance expert who worked for Senator Ron Wyden for a decade, noted that AT&T provides wholesale services to other carriers. This allows AT&T to collect, save, and mine records of calls made by customers of other companies, including conversations where both parties use non-AT&T providers.
- Capabilities: A document previously obtained by Senator Wyden's office outlines specific capabilities, including:
- Linking multiple devices or phone numbers to an identified target.
- Identifying devices that have had their SIM cards replaced.
- Determining if phones associated with international targets have entered the U.S.
- Deconflicting international phone numbers associated with targets.
- Volume: Documents previously obtained by the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) and the Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC) indicate the AT&T program contains more than a trillion phone records.
Legal Concerns and Lack of Oversight
While AT&T told 404 Media that data is made available only under valid legal orders, experts point out that the process relies on administrative subpoenas. These can be issued by agencies themselves without requiring a judge's approval, raising concerns that ICE could use the data for virtually any purpose.
Furthermore, Jeramie Scott, senior counsel at EPIC and director of EPIC's Surveillance Oversight Program, highlighted potential legal violations regarding location data:
- Carpenter v. United States: Ruled that law enforcement needs a warrant to obtain historical cell-site location information.
- Chatrie: Made similar judgments regarding location data and geofence warrants.
Scott stated, "ICE is now taking advantage of AT&T's surveillance as a service model while likely evading any judicial oversight and conducting no privacy impact assessment prior to using the service to determine whether it should be used in the first place."
Financial Incentives and Contract Details
Public procurement records reveal significant financial commitments from ICE to AT&T:
- 2025 Payments: ICE paid AT&T more than $2.1 million in 2025 for access to the service.
- August 2025 Payment: An additional $2.2 million was paid in August.
- Future Projections: There is a possibility of paying up to $10 million over the coming years.
A restricted document obtained via a Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) request reveals that the Office of Acquisition Management (OAQ) intends to procure these services on a sole-source basis. The document states:
"AT&T is the only vendor who possesses the ability to access AT&T owned raw data... If AT&T does not execute the analytical work, the capability will be lost, as no other company has access to the data required."
The document notes that during Fiscal Year 2025, there was higher demand for the data, and "further significant increase in use is anticipated." While the contract supports "a wide range of HSI [Homeland Security Investigations] investigations and agency priorities," the specific types of investigations are redacted.
HSI, traditionally focused on cybercrime and child abuse cases, has dramatically refocused under the Trump administration on immigration violations and investigating voter fraud.
Political Reactions
Senator Ron Wyden
Senator Ron Wyden criticized the move as a resurrection of the banned Hemisphere program.
"The Biden administration shut down Hemisphere after I and Rep. Biggs repeatedly questioned this warrantless mass phone surveillance program. 404 Media's reporting shows that the Trump-Vance administration has created a zombie version of Hemisphere surveillance, and given it to their chosen enforcers at ICE."
Wyden added, "Americans are pushing back on government surveillance, from Flock cameras to FISA, all across the country and will be rightfully outraged that AT&T is allowing ICE to search through its customers' phone records without a warrant or court oversight."
Christopher Soghoian
Soghoian emphasized the inability of consumers to opt-out of this surveillance.
"It's bad enough that AT&T is mining its customers' private phone records as a paid service for ICE, but because AT&T is also mining the records of other wholesale telecom companies, consumers can't vote with their wallets and switch carriers to protect their privacy."
He concluded, "Hemisphere is a surveillance program that refuses to die and keeps coming back with different names and different forms. It is now clear that the Biden White House misled Congress when it said that Hemisphere had been shut down."
Official Responses
AT&T responded to 404 Media via email:
"For decades, we have been a trusted partner to provide reliable connectivity to federal agencies as well as state and local governments. We are required by law to provide information to government and law enforcement agencies when it is demanded under lawful order. We ensure that these requests are valid, and that our responses comply with the law."
ICE did not respond to multiple requests for comment but previously told the Financial Times:
"Nothing new here. For years law enforcement across the nation has leveraged technological innovation to fight crime. ICE is no different."
Context: The History of Hemisphere
The precursor to the current Data Analytical Services was the Hemisphere program, first revealed by The New York Times in 2013. In that program, AT&T employees sat alongside Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) agents, supplying phone data dating back to 1987. Federal funding for Hemisphere was stopped in September 2024, and the program was officially shut down. However, documents suggest Data Analytical Services was previously called Hemisphere, indicating a direct lineage between the two initiatives.
Source
Hacker NewsNeutral / independent
Part of this Story
ICE Pays AT&T Millions to Access Trillions of Phone Records