Investigation: PG&E Funneled Over $1M to Newsom Orbit for Safety Certificate
Editorial responsibility
- No named human review is recorded for this page.
- Source reporting is collected, normalized, translated or condensed automatically when needed.
- Automatically published source-backed update
An investigation by City Journal alleges that Pacific Gas and Electric (PG&E) funneled over $1 million in donations to Governor Gavin Newsom, his wife's nonprofit, and his political agenda over nearly three decades. The article claims these financial contributions were reciprocated when the governor signed legislation shielding utilities from wildfire liabilities and approved a crucial safety certificate for PG&E following the deadly 2018 Camp Fire. While PG&E pleaded guilty to manslaughter counts related to the fire, the report suggests the utility leveraged its political influence to avoid ruinous damages while ratepayers faced nearly 70% bill increases since 2020. The authors assert this constitutes a scheme where the utility effectively 'bought' political favors, though the article presents these as allegations based on financial records and internal emails rather than proven legal facts.
Source report
By Christopher F. Rufo, Susan Crabtree, and Kenneth Schrupp Published: November 18, 2026 | Topics: States and Cities, Infrastructure and Energy, Politics and Law
The Disaster in Paradise
Paradise, California, was once a quiet town in the Sierra Nevada foothills, known for affordable homes, abundant land, and small-town charm. For over a century, it served as an oasis from urban life. That changed on November 8, 2018, when a hook suspended from a Pacific Gas and Electric (PG&E) tower snapped. A jumper conductor struck the tower, melting metal strands and igniting nearby vegetation.
The resulting Camp Fire destroyed Paradise and its surroundings:
- 150,000 acres were incinerated.
- Thousands of homes were leveled.
- 85 people were killed.
In the five years following the fire, Paradise's population shrank by more than half. PG&E eventually pleaded guilty to 84 counts of manslaughter. In the wake of the disaster, the utility faced over $10 billion in damages and insurance claims.
The Political Bailout
Despite the catastrophe, PG&E received crucial aid from Governor Gavin Newsom. Shortly after taking office, Newsom signed legislation shielding utilities from ruinous future wildfire liabilities. This law established a multibillion-dollar insurance fund financed in part by ratepayers. Consequently, PG&E bills have risen nearly 70 percent since 2020.
Why would a governor champion one of California's most unpopular companies? An investigation into financial records, whistleblower testimony, and exclusive internal emails from the state's Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) reveals a straightforward scheme: PG&E funneled cash to entities linked to Newsom, his wife, and his political agenda; in return, the governor's office worked to benefit PG&E, including reviewing and approving a crucial safety license.
A Decades-Long Financial Relationship
California utilities frequently lobby politicians for favors. PG&E cultivated a relationship with Newsom spanning nearly 30 years, donating at least $1 million to entities linked to him, his wife, or his causes. These contributions were particularly vital early in Newsom's career.
Timeline of Contributions:
- 2002: $10,000 to then-San Francisco Supervisor Newsom's homeless-aid initiative.
- 2004–2008: $25,000 total directed to his mayoral inaugurations.
- 2011: A $5,000 behested payment solicited by Newsom for his lieutenant governor inauguration host committee.
- 2013–2014: Over $10,000 directed to Newsom's reelection campaign for lieutenant governor.
- 2018 Elections: Two major payments totaling $208,400 ($58,400 directly to his campaign and $150,000 to a Newsom-aligned committee).
- 2011–2018: Over $350,000 donated to The Representation Project, a nonprofit run by Newsom's wife, Jennifer Siebel Newsom. The company earned credits on her films Miss Representation and The Mask You Live In.
Although Newsom's spokesman claimed in 2019 that the governor stopped accepting money from PG&E after his election, the utility continued to bankroll his agenda:
- 2020: $250,000 steered to support Proposition 16 (a measure to roll back California's ban on affirmative action), which Newsom endorsed.
- Later in 2020: Another $250,000 directed to support Proposition 1, a mental-health initiative that passed with less than 51% of the vote.
The Safety Certificate Controversy
Following the Paradise fire, PG&E faced criminal indictments, 11-figure liabilities, and potential bankruptcy. Its only hope was a massive bailout via A.B. 1054, signed by Newsom in 2019. This bill created a $21 billion Wildfire Fund to cover fire-related expenses for utilities that acted "reasonably."
To access this fund, utilities could obtain a "safety certification" from the CPUC. If awarded before a fire occurs, the utility is rebuttably presumed to have acted reasonably, limiting its exposure. Without the certificate, a utility could be forced to repay the fund in full.
The Stakes
Months after the Camp Fire, the CPUC had to decide whether to award PG&E this certificate. The stakes were immense:
- With the certificate: PG&E would gain presumptive access to the Wildfire Fund for any disasters caused over the next 12 months.
- Without the certificate: The utility faced uncapped costs on top of existing liabilities.
In August 2019, just three weeks after the request, the commission awarded PG&E the safety certificate. However, internal communications suggest the decision was not made in isolation.
Whistleblower Revelations and Internal Emails
We spoke to a whistleblower and reviewed exclusive internal CPUC emails indicating that Governor Newsom's office reviewed and approved the safety certificate awarded to PG&E. Following this approval, PG&E's equipment contributed to multiple other fires, killing four additional people.
Alice Stebbins, appointed CPUC executive director in 2018, alleged she was fired in September 2020 for finding financial irregularities. Her lawyer described her as the "voice of change" in an "insane asylum." Stebbins provided a trove of emails from August 2019 revealing:
- Multiple commissioners discussed the prospect of the "GO" (Governor's Office) reviewing the CPUC's deliberations.
- Elizaveta Malashenko, a safety official, raised concerns about how to handle "PG&E's implementation of safety culture recommendations," calling it an "open question."
- Lonn Maier, a project supervisor, highlighted PG&E's alleged failures to implement fire-prevention measures at its "Fulton – Fitch" project.
Despite these concerns, Commission Counsel J. Jason Reiger advised against considering the alleged failures, citing an earlier consultant review. He wrote:
"The short answer is that I don't think [the earlier findings] are related enough to bring the Fulton Fitch situation into the Safety Certificate process."
Reiger further claimed that A.B. 1054 represented a "minimum standard," suggesting the CPUC could impose stricter regulations but chose not to.
Conclusion
This investigation details how Pacific Gas and Electric effectively bought influence over Governor Gavin Newsom. Through decades of strategic donations to the governor, his family, and his political causes, PG&E secured a legislative bailout and a critical safety certification that shielded it from liability, even as its failures continued to endanger lives.
Source
City JournalNeutral / independent