South Carolina Board Unanimously Denies Parole to Susan Smith for Second Time
The South Carolina Board of Probation, Parole and Pardon Services unanimously denied parole to Susan Smith on November 19, 2026, marking the second rejection since she became eligible in 2024. Convicted in 1994 for drowning her two young sons, Michael and Alex, by strapping them into a car and rolling it into John D. Long Lake, Smith argued before the board that she has matured and expressed deep remorse. However, the seven-member board cited the deliberate nature of the crime and strong opposition from the victims' father, David Smith, who called release a 'huge injustice.' Smith may apply again in two years.
Editorial responsibility
- No named human review is recorded for this page.
- Reports are grouped by semantic similarity and deterministic rules. Language models may assist titles, summaries, translation and cross-source analysis; the page reads the event directly, while its address stays stable when the title changes.
- Summary covers the current reports
Cross-source coverage
Reporting timeline
Susan Smith Denied Parole 32 Years After Drowning Her Two Sons
The South Carolina parole board unanimously denied parole to Susan Smith, who was convicted in 1994 of drowning her two young sons, Michael and Alex, by strapping them into a car and rolling it into a lake. The decision comes 32 years after the crime, during which Smith initially falsely claimed a Black man had abducted the children before confessing. Now 55, Smith argued before the board that she has matured and carries deep remorse for the 'unbearable pain' she caused. However, the boys' father, David Smith, strongly opposed her release, stating that setting her free would be a 'huge injustice' and emphasizing that the loss feels as recent as yesterday. This marks the second time in two years that Smith's parole request has been denied, following an initial denial in 2024.
Read sourceSusan Smith Denied Parole Again 32 Years After Killing Her Sons
The South Carolina parole board unanimously denied Susan Smith's request for release on Thursday, marking the second denial since she became eligible in 2024. Smith, now 55, was sentenced to life in prison in 1994 for drowning her two young sons, Michael and Alex, in a lake after falsely claiming they were kidnapped by a carjacker. During the virtual hearing, Smith expressed remorse, stating she is not the same person she was 32 years ago and asked for a chance to do good. However, the boys' father, David Smith, strongly opposed her release, testifying that the crime was deliberate and that he still feels the loss as if it happened yesterday. Original prosecutors also argued that Smith killed the children out of selfishness to pursue a new relationship and noted her history of seeking attention through lies. The board granted parole in only 4% of cases, mostly non-violent ones, making her release highly unlikely.
Read sourceSusan Smith Denied Parole Again 32 Years After Killing Two Sons
Susan Smith, a South Carolina woman convicted of drowning her two sons in 1994, was denied parole for the second time by the state board. During the hearing, Smith expressed deep remorse, stating she wished she could change the past and that her children 'did not deserve to die.' She argued she has matured since the crime, though prosecutors noted her initial claim of being carjacked was false. The father of the victims, David Smith, attended the hearing to oppose her release, calling it a 'huge injustice' regardless of the 32 years passed. Smith's lawyers had previously suggested a mental breakdown contributed to the act, but the seven-member board unanimously rejected her request. Under current laws, she may apply again in two years.
Read sourceShow 2 older updatesHide older updates
Susan Smith Denied Parole Again 32 Years After Drowning Her Two Sons
Susan Smith, a South Carolina woman convicted of drowning her two young sons in 1994, was denied parole for the second time by the state board. The seven-member board unanimously rejected her request after she expressed remorse and claimed personal growth over the past three decades. Smith admitted to strapping her children into their car seats and driving into a lake, initially claiming a carjacking before confessing. During the hearing, she stated that the crime was not caused by an affair as prosecutors originally alleged, but rather by a desire to die with her children. Her ex-husband, David Smith, attended the hearing to oppose her release, arguing that granting parole would be a 'huge injustice' to the victims. Despite Smith's assertion that she is no longer the person she was 32 years ago, the board maintained that the deliberate nature of the crime outweighs her rehabilitation claims.
Read sourceSusan Smith Parole Request Denied Unanimously 32 Years After Killing Sons
The South Carolina Department of Probations, Pardons and Parole Services has unanimously denied Susan Smith's request for parole. This marks the second time her release has been rejected, following a previous denial in November 2024. Smith is serving a life sentence with the possibility of parole after 30 years for the 1994 drowning deaths of her two sons, Alex (14 months) and Michael (3), in John D. Long Lake. The case gained national attention when Smith initially falsely claimed a Black man had carjacked her vehicle before confessing to the crime nine days later. A jury convicted her on July 22, 1995. Despite the passage of over three decades, the parole board has not granted her freedom, citing the severity of the crimes against her children.
Read source