Contradictions of Socialist Prison Abolitionism

This opinion article from Reason.com argues that 'democratic socialist' prison abolitionism is fundamentally contradictory. The author contends that socialism, defined as government control of most or all of the economy, requires criminalizing numerous economic activities (e.g., for-profit provision of food, energy, medicine). These laws necessitate enforcement through punishment, leading to increased incarceration, not less. The article cites the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) as an example of a group advocating both socialism and prison abolition. It draws on historical examples from the Soviet Union, where black markets flourished due to shortages, and socialist governments used coercion to suppress them. The author concludes that attempts to significantly reduce incarceration while implementing socialism are unworkable, as the tension is inherent.