Vogue Editor Plum Sykes Criticized for Using Unpaid Interns
American Vogue contributor Plum Sykes has faced significant backlash after publicly admitting to using unpaid interns to manage her successful Substack newsletter. Sykes described students performing substantive tasks, including editing copy, writing captions, and managing social media, sometimes for extended periods. She defended the arrangement as casual, voluntary work experience rather than formal employment. However, critics argue this practice is illegal under labor standards that distinguish between shadowing and productive work. The incident highlights broader ethical concerns regarding exploitation in the media industry and the reinforcement of class barriers. By relying on unpaid labor, the industry effectively excludes working-class individuals who cannot afford to work without wages, thereby perpetuating a lack of diversity. This controversy echoes themes from 'The Devil Wears Prada' and follows recent discussions about the BBC's failure to recruit working-class journalists. Research indicates that such practices contribute to the erasure of working-class voices in journalism, with the majority of journalists now coming from professional or upper-class backgrounds, thus maintaining privilege as the primary access code for media careers.
Wire timeline
Vogue Editor Plum Sykes Criticized for Using Unpaid Interns
American Vogue contributor Plum Sykes has faced significant backlash after publicly admitting to using unpaid interns to manage her successful Substack newsletter. Sykes described students performing substantive tasks, including editing copy, writing captions, and managing social media, sometimes for extended periods. She defended the arrangement as casual, voluntary work experience rather than formal employment. However, critics argue this practice is illegal under labor standards that distinguish between shadowing and productive work. The incident highlights broader ethical concerns regarding exploitation in the media industry and the reinforcement of class barriers. By relying on unpaid labor, the industry effectively excludes working-class individuals who cannot afford to work without wages, thereby perpetuating a lack of diversity. This controversy echoes themes from 'The Devil Wears Prada' and follows recent discussions about the BBC's failure to recruit working-class journalists. Research indicates that such practices contribute to the erasure of working-class voices in journalism, with the majority of journalists now coming from professional or upper-class backgrounds, thus maintaining privilege as the primary access code for media careers.
independent