Harvard Faculty Votes to Cap A Grades at 20% to Combat Grade Inflation
Harvard University faculty voted 458-201 to cap A grades at 20% per undergraduate course, starting in the 2027-28 academic year, to address severe grade inflation. Currently, 60-85% of grades are A’s, up from 25% two decades ago. The “20+4” rule aims to restore A’s as marks of “extraordinary distinction.” A separate internal ranking system passed with 75% support. Critics argue the cap adds pressure, but proponents see it as necessary for academic rigor.
Editorial summary awaiting refresh
Cross-source coverage
Wire timeline
Harvard Limits Outstanding Grades to 20% Per Course to Combat Grade Inflation
Harvard University has approved new regulations that will limit the proportion of outstanding grades (e.g., A or A+) awarded in each undergraduate course to a maximum of 20%. The policy, set to take effect in the 2027 academic cycle, aims to counteract grade inflation and restore more differentiated criteria for assessing academic performance. The move is intended to make grading more rigorous and meaningful, ensuring that top grades are reserved for truly exceptional work. The decision reflects ongoing concerns at elite universities about the erosion of grading standards and the need to provide clearer signals of student achievement to employers and graduate schools.
Infobae.comHarvard Faculty Votes to Cap A Grades at 20% to Combat Grade Inflation
Harvard University's faculty voted 458-201 to implement a 20% cap on A grades starting in the 2027-2028 school year, following a report showing 60.2% of grades awarded in 2024-2025 were A's—up from 25% two decades ago. The policy allows professors to give four additional A's per course enrollment. A 2025 report attributed grade inflation to professors' unwillingness to be seen as demanding, increasingly litigious students, and pressure to provide emotional support, which led to relaxed requirements and higher grades, especially during remote instruction. Harvard joins other elite schools grappling with the issue: Yale recommended a 3.0 mean GPA standard, while Princeton abandoned a similar cap in 2014 after criticism that it disadvantaged students in job and graduate school competition. Students have criticized the new policy as adding pressure to an already demanding environment. Harvard's dean of Undergraduate Education called grade inflation a 'complex and thorny issue' but urged other institutions to confront it with 'rigor and courage.'
Reason.comHarvard Faculty Votes to Cap A Grades at 20% to Combat Grade Inflation
Harvard University faculty voted nearly 70% in favor of a proposal to limit the number of A grades awarded in undergraduate courses, starting in the 2027-28 academic year. The policy caps A grades at 20% of enrolled students per class, with an additional four students allowed for small seminar-style courses. The vote, involving 659 faculty members, aims to address decades of grade inflation that saw A's represent two-thirds of all letter grades last year. Proponents argue the change will restore the meaning of an A as a mark of 'extraordinary distinction' and encourage academic rigor. A separate measure to implement an internal ranking system for honors and prizes passed with 75% support. The pandemic accelerated discussions, as grading became more generous. Students expressed disapproval in a February poll, though some have since warmed to the proposal after implementation was delayed by a year. The policy will be reviewed after three years. Yale has floated a similar idea to restrict average GPAs to a 3.0.
WBUR NewsHarvard Faculty Vote on Proposal to Cap A Grades to Combat Inflation
Harvard University faculty are voting on a significant proposal to cap the number of A grades awarded in undergraduate courses, aiming to address severe grade inflation. Currently, A grades constitute the majority of marks given, with 85% of all grades falling within the A range last year, a sharp increase from two decades ago when they represented only a quarter of grades. The proposed "20 + 4" rule would limit pure A grades to no more than 20% of students per course, plus an additional four students to accommodate smaller classes. Advocates argue that rampant grade inflation has diluted the meaning of academic distinction and fostered a culture of perfectionism, discouraging students from taking intellectual risks. Under the new system, A grades would account for approximately 34% of all grades, returning to 2011 levels. While some faculty members criticize the measure as clumsy and an infringement on academic autonomy, they support it as a necessary step to restore grades as meaningful indicators of performance. The vote also includes considerations for an internal percentile ranking system and a new "Satisfactory-plus" grading option.
WBUR NewsHarvard Faculty Vote on Proposal to Cap A Grades to Combat Inflation
Harvard University faculty are voting on a significant proposal to cap the number of A grades awarded in undergraduate courses, aiming to address severe grade inflation. Currently, A grades constitute the majority of marks given, with 85% of all grades falling within the A range last year, a sharp increase from two decades ago when they represented only a quarter of grades. The proposed "20 + 4" rule would limit pure A grades to no more than 20% of students per course, plus an additional four students to accommodate smaller classes. Advocates argue that rampant grade inflation has diluted the meaning of academic distinction and discouraged intellectual risk-taking, as students increasingly expect perfect scores. Under the new system, A grades would account for approximately 34% of all marks, returning to 2011 levels. While some faculty members criticize the plan as arbitrary and restrictive of academic autonomy, they support it as a necessary step to restore grades as meaningful indicators of performance. The vote also includes measures for internal percentile rankings and a new "Satisfactory-plus" grading option, reflecting a broader effort to recalibrate academic standards at the Ivy League institution.
WBUR News