Guardian Review: Taiwan's Hit 'Sunshine Women’s Choir' Drowns in Sentimentality
The Guardian publishes a scathing review of 'Sunshine Women’s Choir,' a prison musical that has become the biggest local box office hit in Taiwanese history. Despite its commercial success, the critic condemns the film as manipulative and overly sentimental, arguing it provokes exasperation rather than genuine emotion. Adapted from the 2010 Korean film 'Harmony,' the story follows Hui-Zhen, an inmate raising her infant daughter behind bars after killing her abusive husband. To secure medical treatment for her child’s cataracts and say a proper farewell, she forms a choir with fellow prisoners. The review criticizes director Gavin Lin for relying on clichéd tropes, sanitized prison conditions, and contrived melodrama, including unnecessary flashbacks and tragic subplots like a character’s cancer diagnosis. The critic suggests the filmmakers should be banned from future projects due to the movie's excessive schmaltz and lack of narrative grit. While acknowledging the film's popularity in Taiwan, the article highlights a stark contrast between local audience reception and Western critical standards, describing the production as a danger to public cinematic taste.
Wire timeline
Guardian Review: Taiwan's Hit 'Sunshine Women’s Choir' Drowns in Sentimentality
The Guardian publishes a scathing review of 'Sunshine Women’s Choir,' a prison musical that has become the biggest local box office hit in Taiwanese history. Despite its commercial success, the critic condemns the film as manipulative and overly sentimental, arguing it provokes exasperation rather than genuine emotion. Adapted from the 2010 Korean film 'Harmony,' the story follows Hui-Zhen, an inmate raising her infant daughter behind bars after killing her abusive husband. To secure medical treatment for her child’s cataracts and say a proper farewell, she forms a choir with fellow prisoners. The review criticizes director Gavin Lin for relying on clichéd tropes, sanitized prison conditions, and contrived melodrama, including unnecessary flashbacks and tragic subplots like a character’s cancer diagnosis. The critic suggests the filmmakers should be banned from future projects due to the movie's excessive schmaltz and lack of narrative grit. While acknowledging the film's popularity in Taiwan, the article highlights a stark contrast between local audience reception and Western critical standards, describing the production as a danger to public cinematic taste.
The Guardian