ECJ Rules Bavarian Family Allowance Violates EU Law
The European Court of Justice (ECJ) has ruled that Bavaria’s practice of indexing family benefits based on the cost of living in other EU member states violates European law. The court determined that this stratification breaches the principle of equal treatment for employees across the EU, as established in previous rulings against similar Austrian policies. Consequently, workers whose children reside in countries with lower living costs, such as Poland or Romania, must receive the same allowance amounts as those with children in Germany. Bavarian Family Minister Ulrike Scharf acknowledged the ruling and confirmed that the state will adjust its practices accordingly. However, she maintained that adjusting benefits to local living standards is logically sound and announced that Bavaria will advocate for changes to EU regulations at the federal level. The decision raises questions about potential back payments for affected families, a matter on which the court remained silent. Meanwhile, Bavaria plans to restrict the family allowance to children born before January 1, 2025, redirecting funds toward childcare infrastructure amid broader austerity measures.
Wire timeline
ECJ Rules Bavarian Family Allowance Violates EU Law
The European Court of Justice (ECJ) has ruled that Bavaria’s practice of indexing family benefits based on the cost of living in other EU member states violates European law. The court determined that this stratification breaches the principle of equal treatment for employees across the EU, as established in previous rulings against similar Austrian policies. Consequently, workers whose children reside in countries with lower living costs, such as Poland or Romania, must receive the same allowance amounts as those with children in Germany. Bavarian Family Minister Ulrike Scharf acknowledged the ruling and confirmed that the state will adjust its practices accordingly. However, she maintained that adjusting benefits to local living standards is logically sound and announced that Bavaria will advocate for changes to EU regulations at the federal level. The decision raises questions about potential back payments for affected families, a matter on which the court remained silent. Meanwhile, Bavaria plans to restrict the family allowance to children born before January 1, 2025, redirecting funds toward childcare infrastructure amid broader austerity measures.
Aktuell - FAZ.NET