Authors Debate Fragile Masculinity: Crisis or Systemic Issue?
German authors Tobias Haberl and Ole Liebl engage in a critical dialogue regarding the concept of fragile masculinity, following the publication of their respective books on the subject. Haberl argues that masculinity is inherently prone to crisis and suggests that current perceptions are amplified by media logic and political manipulation by far-right groups. He defends traditional male models against what he sees as an overly polite, feminine societal expectation. In contrast, Liebl contends that describing masculinity as being in crisis ignores historical context. He asserts that for many women and queer individuals, masculinity itself constitutes the crisis, deeply rooted in performance-based cultural norms. Liebl emphasizes that recent high-profile sexual violence cases are not symptoms of new fragility but rather results of a patriarchal system of silence that protects perpetrators and hides shame. The discussion highlights diverging views on whether modern masculinity is a victim of social change or a persistent source of structural violence, offering nuanced perspectives on gender roles, emotional expression, and the socio-political exploitation of male identity in contemporary Western society.
Wire timeline
Authors Debate Fragile Masculinity: Crisis or Systemic Issue?
German authors Tobias Haberl and Ole Liebl engage in a critical dialogue regarding the concept of fragile masculinity, following the publication of their respective books on the subject. Haberl argues that masculinity is inherently prone to crisis and suggests that current perceptions are amplified by media logic and political manipulation by far-right groups. He defends traditional male models against what he sees as an overly polite, feminine societal expectation. In contrast, Liebl contends that describing masculinity as being in crisis ignores historical context. He asserts that for many women and queer individuals, masculinity itself constitutes the crisis, deeply rooted in performance-based cultural norms. Liebl emphasizes that recent high-profile sexual violence cases are not symptoms of new fragility but rather results of a patriarchal system of silence that protects perpetrators and hides shame. The discussion highlights diverging views on whether modern masculinity is a victim of social change or a persistent source of structural violence, offering nuanced perspectives on gender roles, emotional expression, and the socio-political exploitation of male identity in contemporary Western society.
taz.de - taz.de