Anna's Archive Ordered to Pay $322 Million for Scraping Spotify
A New York federal judge has ordered the open-source library Anna’s Archive to pay $322 million in damages to Spotify and three major record labels for illegally scraping music data. The lawsuit, initially filed in January with a claim of $13 trillion, alleged that Anna’s Archive scraped 86 million songs with intent to distribute them via BitTorrent. The court found the archive guilty of direct copyright infringement, breach of contract, and violation of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA), though a claim under the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act was dismissed. The damages breakdown awards $300 million to Spotify, calculated at $2,500 per each of the 120,000 files already released, while Sony and Universal Music Group receive $7.5 million each, and Warner Music Group receives $7.2 million. The judge also mandated the immediate destruction of all scraped content. However, enforcement remains uncertain as the operators behind Anna’s Archive are anonymous and failed to respond to the lawsuit. This case highlights ongoing tensions between digital preservation efforts and intellectual property rights in the streaming era.
Wire timeline
Anna's Archive Ordered to Pay $322 Million for Scraping Spotify
A New York federal judge has ordered the open-source library Anna’s Archive to pay $322 million in damages to Spotify and three major record labels for illegally scraping music data. The lawsuit, initially filed in January with a claim of $13 trillion, alleged that Anna’s Archive scraped 86 million songs with intent to distribute them via BitTorrent. The court found the archive guilty of direct copyright infringement, breach of contract, and violation of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA), though a claim under the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act was dismissed. The damages breakdown awards $300 million to Spotify, calculated at $2,500 per each of the 120,000 files already released, while Sony and Universal Music Group receive $7.5 million each, and Warner Music Group receives $7.2 million. The judge also mandated the immediate destruction of all scraped content. However, enforcement remains uncertain as the operators behind Anna’s Archive are anonymous and failed to respond to the lawsuit. This case highlights ongoing tensions between digital preservation efforts and intellectual property rights in the streaming era.
Engadget is a web magazine with obsessive daily coverage of everything new in gadgets and consumer electronics